# Config Watch #15

**WEEKLY · CONFIG WATCH**  ·  Issue #15  ·  the ceiling rises and the board with it

Issue date: November 18, 2026  ·  Language: English  ·  Methodology v1.1 + Config Watch amendments (approved 12.08, hash e66c7e8c864a2233)

Search windows: **WK** Nov 9-16, 2026 and **M30** Oct 19-Nov 16, 2026 -- both frozen and Monday-aligned (WK = Mon Nov 9 00:00 -> Sun Nov 15 23:59 UTC; M30 = Mon Oct 19 00:00 -> Sun Nov 15 23:59 UTC, 4 full weeks), sharing the cut-off edge Mon Nov 16 00:00 UTC, so slots dated Nov 16 fall outside both.

*Slots fall inside the window; trades settle past its right edge at their horizon -- the same 2-3 day luft the engine has used since issue #1 and that the live presets run on.*

PDF: https://marketmania.ai/research/reports/config-watch-2026-11-11.pdf · Open data (JSON): https://marketmania.ai/research/reports/config-watch-2026-11-11.json

---

## Snapshot

- **15,727** simulations, 0 errors, in two frozen collects
- **WK** Nov 9-16, 2026
- **M30** Oct 19-Nov 16, 2026
- 7-stage search: scan -> grid -> refine -> stake sweep -> per-ticker -> OOS replays
- engine 1.1; **$1,000** deposit, **10x** leverage
- stake is **universe-aware** from sim #1 (table below)
- maturity gate: >=**15** closed (WK) / >=**20** (M30)
- criteria frozen in writing before launch (w404 plan)
- walk-forward: **92** past cards + **4** live presets replayed verbatim on both windows
- **37 of 92** past cards Survive (net-positive on both windows)
- stability: **5** configs across WK and M30 (night run)
- models: **7** (both windows on the new builds)
- best WK council **+$1,119.3** (+111.9%)
- best M30 council **+$1,413.4** (+141.3%)
- zero-trade cells: **1,090** (weekly) / **1,929** (night run)
- margin-skip alerts on leaders: **6** (WK) / **12** (M30) rows

---

## KEY FINDING

> **[OBSERVATION (the ceiling rises and the board with it)]** The ceiling of the fresh search moved from +$538.1 to +$1,119.3 on the week and 62 of the 92 cards this series has published are net-positive on that same week, and under the standing two-window rule 37 of the 92 Survive: 41 clear the month, 62 clear the week.

---

## TL;DR

- OBSERVATION -- **The standing board grew to 92 cards.** Issue #14 kept 24 of its 87 past cards under the same rule; this issue replays **92 cards** -- issues #1, #2, #3, #4, #5, #6, #7, #8, #9, #10, #11, #12, #13, #14, Monthly Config Watch #1, #2 and #3 and Quarterly Config Watch #1 -- on two fresh windows, and **37 of the 92 Survive** (net-positive on both). On the week alone 62 of 92 are positive, on the four-week window 41 of 92. Issue #14's own week champion, replayed verbatim, makes +$124.3 on the week and +$28.4 on the month.
- **The search ceiling, window by window.** The best mature council on WK makes +$1,119.3 (+111.9% of a $1,000 deposit, 62.5% win rate, 2.3% maxDD, 64 closed) against issue #14's +$538.1; on M30 it makes +$1,413.4 (+141.3%, 74.4% win rate, 24.1% maxDD, 39 closed) against issue #14's +$1,508.6. The grids behind them: median +$62.7 with 55.7% positive across 3,824 WK cells (783 of them above +$500), median $0.0 with 38.4% positive across 3,824 M30 cells (474 above +$500).
- **Calibration and the universe, window by window.** Across the whole stage-2 grid calibration improves 7.2% of the 1,271 matched WK pairs (mean -$218.3) and 32.3% of the 1,280 matched M30 pairs (mean -$86.4); pooled, 19.8% of 2,551. On the cards, **no published WK council is a calibrated cell** and **no M30 card is a calibrated cell**. The mature net top-10 leans on one universe per window: BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP on WK (5 of 10 slots), SOL+XRP on M30 (9 of 10).
- **The stability board, a twelfth reading of the same pair.** The night collect computes WK and M30 in one pass, so this issue's cross-window board is measured on the two windows the issue prints -- and **5 configurations** are in the mature net top-40 of both. Issue #14 measured the same pair one week earlier and held 4, issue #13 the week before that 0, issue #12 1, issue #11 0, issue #10 4, issue #9 7, issue #8 4, issue #7 16, issue #6 9, issue #5 0 and issue #3 21. The hand-tuned anchor keeps its standing measurement against the whole mature field of each window -- 0 of 1,981 mature WK configs and 285 of 2,941 mature M30 configs beat it on win rate, maxDD and smoothness at the same time. Net PnL stays the headline board (continuity with issues #1-#14).

---

## Stage-2 grid: where the defaults sit (WK)

![WK stage-2 grid net PnL histogram](chart_hist_wk.png)

*Net PnL across all 3,824 stage-2 grid sims, WK window (Nov 9-16, 2026), universe-aware stake throughout. Grid median **+$62.7**, 55.7% positive (issue #14's week: median $0.0, 32.3% positive; its month: $0.0, 49.0% positive). The spike at $0 is mostly cells whose entry filters produced no trades (1,038 zero-trade sims on this window). Range -$638.3 to +$1,119.4; 783 cells finished above +$500. Red marker = best solo default at table stake; green = the published cards. The same board definition one week earlier put its top-5 at +$538.1 down to +$440.7; this week it runs +$1,119.3 down to +$1,050.6 -- a property of the week, not evidence about either issue's cards. The M30 histogram appears after the M30 cards. Source: grid_hist_wk.json.*

---

## Why it matters

MarketMania publishes default LLM-council trading configs. This series asks one narrower question every week: how much apparent performance can large-scale in-sample search extract -- and how much of it survives out-of-sample? Issue #1 set the in-sample baseline, issue #2 delivered the first walk-forward verdict (brutal), issue #3 the second (the opposite), issue #4 the third on two windows at once, issue #5 the fourth, issue #6 the fifth, issue #7 the sixth, issue #8 the seventh, issue #9 the eighth, issue #10 the ninth, issue #11 the tenth, issue #12 the eleventh, issue #13 the twelfth and issue #14 the thirteenth, each on the widest board the series had had. Issue #15 delivers the fourteenth, on a board that carries every generation the series has produced: 92 cards from fourteen weekly issues, the first three monthly ones and the first quarterly one, each replayed verbatim on the same two fresh windows. That is the point of the exercise -- a rule that is applied to a growing, never-pruned list is the only walk-forward number that cannot be chosen after the fact.

---

## How we searched

Two frozen collects, run to the same plan with the criteria frozen in writing *before* launch (w404 plan) and printed into the meta of every JSON deliverable: the weekly collect over the WK window, and the night collect, which sweeps the M30 window and the same WK week together in one pass. Each stage below prints **weekly + night** and both totals are printed whole; no calendar-month window is computed this issue. **Every WK number in this issue comes from the weekly collect and every M30 number from the night collect** -- the night run's own second pass over the WK week is used for one thing only, the cross-window stability board, and no number from it is printed beside a weekly-collect number.

1. **1. Scan (s1)** -- 476 + 952 sims across council compositions and coarse settings.
2. **2. Systematic grid (s2)** -- 3,824 + 7,648 sims sweeping the declared axes (archetype, FH/TF, entry filters, universe, council size, membership, TP/SL source, ladder, break-even, TP/SL shift, calibrate and stake) -- the denominator for every distribution claim below.
3. **3. Refinement: ladder + stake sweep (s2b+s3b)** -- 121 + 245 sims around the grid winners.
4. **4. Preset neighbourhood grid (s2p)** -- 53 + 106 sims: one-knob neighbours of the live presets that have a local grid this issue.
5. **5. Per-ticker probes (s5t)** -- 60 + 129 sims: best finalists split onto single coins.
6. **6. Dedicated per-ticker (s6t+s6tc)** -- 540 + 1,125 sims: a compacted independent per-coin grid plus calibrate twins (the standing branch from issue #2).
7. **7. OOS replays (s4cw14+s4cw14o+s4cw13+s4cw13o+s4cwm3+s4cwm3o+s4cw12+s4cw12o+s4cw11+s4cw11o+s4cw10+s4cw10o+s4cwq1+s4cwq1o+s4cw9+s4cw9o+s4cwm2+s4cwm2o+s4cw8+s4cw8o+s4cw7+s4cw7o+s4cw6+s4cw6o+s4cw5+s4cw5o+s4cw4+s4cw4o+s4cwm1+s4cwm1o+s4cw3+s4cw3o+s4cw2+s4cw2o+s4cw1+s4pre)** -- 176 + 272 sims: every published card and all four live presets, verbatim, on every fresh window, plus origin re-runs of the issue-14, Monthly-3 and issue-13 cards for the drift baseline.

*Total 15,727 simulations (5,250 weekly + 10,477 night), 0 errors, 3,019 zero-trade cells (1,090 + 1,929); stage sums reconcile exactly in each collect (counts.by_stage). The axis grid was NOT widened relative to issue #14 (anti-overfit rule): the replay branch grew by one cohort, the search space did not. Equity series, grid histograms, baselines and the calibrate pack are produced inside the same two collects -- there is no separate same-day extras pass this issue.*

### Stake: universe-aware from simulation #1 ($1,000 deposit)

| Instruments in universe | Stake cap | Sweep values also simulated |
|---|---|---|
| 1 coin | $450 | $300 / $375 |
| 2 coins | $450 | $300 / $375 |
| 3 coins | $300 | $225 / $375 |
| 4 coins | $250 | $200 / $300 |
| 5 coins | $200 | $150 / $250 |

*A $1,000 deposit cannot fund five concurrent $450 positions. Stake is a function of how many instruments the config trades, recomputed on every universe change and swept as its own axis; any simulated stake above the cap for its universe size is marked **concentrated** and excluded from the headline boards (it stays in the open data). Every card also prints **skipped_nofunds** -- entries the engine could not fund. Margin-skip alert rows on the leaders this issue publishes: 6 on WK (weekly collect) and 12 on M30 (night collect); the night collect raised 18 alerts in total, the rest on its own second run of the WK week, which this issue does not publish. Source: criteria in both collects.*

*Models under test (engine IDs; claude-opus-5.5 is stored as claude-opus-5-5): claude-fable-5, claude-opus-5.5, gpt-6.1-sol, deepseek-v4-pro, gemini-3.1-pro, qwen-3.8-max, grok-4.7. The Oct 17 model cutover lies two days before M30's left edge: both windows read the successor builds only; cards published before the cutover are replayed on those builds ([remap]). The vendors' names are Claude Opus 5.5, GPT-6.1 Sol and Grok 4.7.*

---

## TOP councils -- WK window (Nov 9-16, 2026)

| # | Council | Coins | FH/TF | Net | Net % | maxDD | Trades | WR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| **#1** | fable, gpt, gemini | SOL+XRP | 4h/4h | **+$1,119.3** | +111.9% | 2.3% | 64 | 62.5% |
| **#2** | gpt, gemini | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | 1d/1d | **+$1,066.7** | +106.7% | 0.0% | 35 \* | 77.1% |

| # | Ladder | BE | Shifts | Conf filter | Source | Entry | Positional | Stake |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | 50:40,100:60 | on | TP -10 / SL +75 | >=60 (each) | farthest | 2/0 | reenter | $450 |
| #2 | 50:40,100:60 | on | TP -10 / SL +75 | >=60 (each) | farthest | 1/0 | reenter | $200 |

*Against the 3,824-cell stage-2 grid on this window: card #1 lands in the +$1,000 to +$1,250 bucket (25 of 3,824 cells) and card #2 in the +$1,000 to +$1,250 bucket (25 cells); 783 cells in the whole grid finished above +$500 (grid median +$62.7). Card percentiles exported this issue cover the raw net-board leaders and the replay rows, not the mature cards -- no percentile is claimed for the two cards themselves. Net % = net PnL as a percentage of the fixed $1,000 starting deposit; every simulation runs at **10x leverage** (liquidation modeled by the engine). Entry = max_sideways / max_diff_side.*

***Two councils are published on this window.** The mature net board carries more than one universe: BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP holds 5 of its ten slots, BNB+XRP 3 and SOL+XRP 2 (card #1 among them). Card #2 is the best mature multi-coin council outside card #1's universe (the pairwise-different-universes rule), and it comes off the mature net board itself (+$1,066.7 on BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP, R2 0.929, ulcer 0.00, 0.0% maxDD, 1 unfunded entry).*

***On the calibrate axis no card is a calibrated cell**, where issue #14 published 0 of its 2 WK councils as calibrated cells. Card #1 runs the 2-coin table stake of $450.  Unfunded entries on the cards: #1 0, #2 1.*

**OPEN IN SANDBOX**   **marketmania.ai/s/cw15-wk1**   **marketmania.ai/s/cw15-wk2**

*Each link opens this exact frozen window; results visible without sign-in (embedded share signature). The codes are minted by the publish script before this file goes live; every card's full frozen query signature is in the open-data JSON next to its simulation index.*

![WK published card equity](chart_equity_wk.png)

*Daily settled equity for card #1 above ($1,000 start, 10x leverage, frozen window; #1 red -- fixed rank colors across all issues). A curve running past the window end is an open-at-cutoff trade settling at its horizon (the 2-3 day luft); the curve's last point reconciles to its config's net to the cent. The muted dashed line is the net-board maximum, drawn for contrast only: at 5 closed trades it sits below the >=15 maturity gate and is not a card. Card #2 has no daily series in this issue's equity pack, and the solo and smoothness series stay in the open data (equity.cards) -- the PDF carries one equity chart per window. Source: equity_wk.json.*

---

## TOP councils -- M30 window (Oct 19-Nov 16, 2026)

| # | Council | Coins | FH/TF | Net | Net % | maxDD | Trades | WR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| **#1** | gpt, gemini | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d,4h | **+$1,413.4** | +141.3% | 24.1% | 39 \* | 74.4% |
| **#2** | gemini, grok | BNB+XRP | 4h/4h,1h | **+$1,267.2** | +126.7% | 41.6% | 102 \* | 65.7% |

| # | Ladder | BE | Shifts | Conf filter | Source | Entry | Positional | Stake |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | 50:40,100:60 | on | TP -10 / SL +75 | >=60 (each) | farthest | 2/0 | reenter | $450 |
| #2 | 50:40,100:60 | on | TP -10 / SL +75 | >=60 (each) | farthest | 2/0 | reenter | $450 |

*Against the 3,824-cell stage-2 grid on this window: card #1 is the same simulation as the raw net-board leader (i=1412), so its exported percentile is the card's -- above **100.0%** of the grid; card #2 lands in the +$1,250 to +$1,500 bucket (4 cells) with 99.9% of the grid finished below it. Grid median $0.0, 474 of the 3,824 cells above +$500. Net % = net PnL as a percentage of the fixed $1,000 starting deposit; every simulation runs at **10x leverage** (liquidation modeled by the engine). Entry = max_sideways / max_diff_side.*

***Two councils are published on this window too.** The mature net board carries more than one universe: SOL+XRP holds 9 of its ten slots (card #1 among them) and BNB+XRP 1. Card #2 is the best mature multi-coin council outside card #1's universe (the pairwise-different-universes rule), and it comes off the mature net board itself (+$1,267.2 on BNB+XRP, R2 0.460, ulcer 18.48, 41.6% maxDD, 13 unfunded entries).*

***On the calibrate axis no M30 card is a calibrated cell**, where no published WK council is a calibrated cell -- the same axis, read on two windows (Calibrate axis below). Card #1 pays for its +$1,413.4 with a **24.1% drawdown** on 39 closed trades and 2 unfunded entries, card #2 with 41.6% on 102 and 13. The M30 mature pool is 2,941 configs against 1,981 on WK, because four weeks clear the >=20-trade gate that one week does not.*

**OPEN IN SANDBOX**   **marketmania.ai/s/cw15-m301**   **marketmania.ai/s/cw15-m302**

*Each link opens this exact frozen window; results visible without sign-in (embedded share signature). The codes are minted by the publish script before this file goes live; every card's full frozen query signature is in the open-data JSON next to its simulation index.*

![M30 published councils equity](chart_equity_m30.png)

*Daily settled equity for card #1 above ($1,000 start, 10x leverage, frozen window; #1 red -- fixed rank colors across all issues). A curve running past the window end is an open-at-cutoff trade settling at its horizon (the 2-3 day luft); its last point reconciles to the card's net to the cent. There is no contrast line on this window: the net-board maximum is the same simulation as card #1 (i=1412, 39 closed, above the >=20 maturity gate). The solo, Calmar, WR and smoothness series stay in the open data (equity.cards) -- the PDF carries one equity chart per window. Source: equity_night.json.*

---

## Stage-2 grid: where the defaults sit (M30)

![M30 stage-2 grid net PnL histogram](chart_hist_m30.png)

*Net PnL across all 3,824 stage-2 grid sims, M30 window (Oct 19-Nov 16, 2026), universe-aware stake throughout. Grid median **$0.0**, 38.4% positive against 55.7% on the week (issue #14's month: median $0.0, 49.0% positive). The spike at $0 is mostly cells whose entry filters produced no trades (819 zero-trade sims on this window). Range -$828.6 to +$1,413.4; 474 cells finished above +$500, against 783 on the week. Red marker = best solo default at table stake; green = the published cards. Source: grid_hist_night.json.*

---

## Walk-forward: the standing OOS verdict

Every config this series has ever published -- all 92 cards from issues #1, #2, #3, #4, #5, #6, #7, #8, #9, #10, #11, #12, #13, #14, Monthly Config Watch #1, #2 and #3 and Quarterly Config Watch #1 -- replayed VERBATIM (same knobs, same stake as printed, no re-tuning) on both fresh windows, plus the four hand-tuned presets running live on the platform, listed first. The 12 cards of the three monthly issues and the quarterly one are judged by the weekly rule, like every other row. The replays and their origin re-runs cost 176 simulations in the weekly collect and 272 in the night collect, which replays every row on both of its own windows.

**Verdict rule, unchanged since issue #2.** **Survived** = net-positive on BOTH fresh windows; **Faded** = net-negative on at least one. The live presets, the monthly cards and the quarterly cards are judged by the same rule. New WK is pure out-of-sample for every row -- the week begins exactly at issue #14's right edge (Nov 9). New M30 (Oct 19-Nov 16, 2026) shares 21 of its 28 days with issue #14's own M30 window (shared stretch Oct 19-Nov 8), 14 of its 28 days with issue #13's own M30 window (shared stretch Oct 19-Nov 1), 7 of its 28 days with issue #12's own M30 window (shared stretch Oct 19-25) and 13 of its 28 days with Monthly Config Watch #3's calendar-October window (shared stretch Oct 19-31), so for those four cohorts that column is decay context rather than pure out-of-sample: the same asymmetry issues #3, #4, #5, #6, #7, #8, #9, #10, #11, #12, #13 and #14 disclosed for their own second columns.

![issue #14 cards: home number vs fresh-week replay](chart_oos_cw14.png)

*Issue #14's 5 published cards: the number its own issue printed (grey, in-sample on its own window) against the same configuration replayed verbatim on this week (green, out-of-sample). 1 of the 5 is net-negative on the fresh week; the 2 M30 cards were measured at home on a four-week window and the 3 WK cards were on a one-week window, so the grey bars are not all the same kind of number. Source: oos_cw14_wk.json + issue #14 open data.*

| Config | Family | Coins | Home | New WK (n) | New M30 (n) | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| **preset 4h4** | fable, qwen, deepseek, opus [remap] | ETH+SOL | -- live | -$55.9 (2) \* | -$554.9 (10) \+ | Faded |
| **preset bc2** | gemini, gpt, deepseek [remap] | SOL+XRP | -- live | +$726.4 (7) \* | +$308.1 (18) \+ | **Survived** |
| **preset sol** | deepseek, fable, opus [remap] | SOL [conc] | -- live | -$238.3 (6) \* | -$426.5 (23) | Faded |
| **preset xrp** | gemini, gpt, deepseek [remap] | XRP [conc] | -- live | +$874.7 (4) \* | -$427.5 (1) \* \+ | Faded |
| cw14-m301 | gpt, grok | SOL+XRP | +$1,508.6 | +$180.9 (11) | +$523.8 (31) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw14-m302 | opus, gpt, deepseek | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | +$671.6 | -$148.6 (2) \* | +$115.7 (13) | Faded |
| cw14-s1 | gpt | SOL+XRP | +$616.4 | +$849.3 (16) | +$1,152.4 (41) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw14-wk1 | fable, opus, gemini, grok | SOL+XRP | +$538.1 | +$124.3 (15) | +$28.4 (48) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw14-wk2 | opus, gpt, grok | BNB+XRP | +$433.3 | +$368.1 (24) | +$523.8 (52) \+ | **Survived** |
| cwm3-m1 | gpt, grok | SOL+XRP | +$1,119.4 | +$658.4 (11) | +$1,080.7 (23) | **Survived** |
| cwm3-m2 | gpt, deepseek | BNB+XRP | +$613.4 | +$421.3 (10) | +$346.8 (30) \+ | **Survived** |
| cwm3-s1 | grok | SOL+XRP | +$1,311.1 | +$413.4 (8) \* | +$1,043.9 (25) | **Survived** |
| cw13-m301 | opus, gpt | SOL+XRP | +$1,046.9 | +$11.9 (6) \* | +$408.9 (13) | **Survived** |
| cw13-m302 | gpt, grok | BTC+ETH | +$373.4 | +$467.1 (12) | -$67.2 (20) \+ | Faded |
| cw13-s1 | fable | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | +$250.8 | +$767.6 (25) | +$938.8 (67) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw13-wk1 | fable, gpt | BTC+ETH+SOL+XRP | +$333.6 | +$423.2 (18) | +$675.0 (63) | **Survived** |
| cw13-wk2 | gemini, gpt, deepseek | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | +$247.1 | +$754.3 (21) | +$800.4 (57) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw12-m301 | opus, gpt | SOL+XRP | +$880.9 | +$357.1 (8) \* | +$527.9 (23) | **Survived** |
| cw12-m302 | gpt, deepseek | BNB+XRP | +$821.0 | +$391.7 (10) | +$403.7 (32) | **Survived** |
| cw12-s1 | gemini | SOL+XRP | +$373.1 | +$52.6 (64) \+ | -$582.2 (173) \+ | Faded |
| cw12-wk1 | fable, gemini | SOL+XRP | +$580.5 | +$794.2 (47) | +$707.0 (149) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw12-wk2 | gpt, gemini, qwen | BTC+ETH | +$333.4 | +$134.8 (19) | -$49.1 (106) \+ | Faded |
| cw11-m301 | gpt, deepseek | SOL+XRP | +$1,484.4 | +$822.1 (13) | +$1,081.3 (33) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw11-m302 | fable, opus, gpt, gemini, qwen | BNB+XRP | +$894.5 | +$14.2 (1) \* | -$280.0 (4) \* \+ | Faded |
| cw11-s1 | gpt | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | +$747.1 | +$774.9 (38) | +$980.4 (114) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw11-wk1 | opus, gpt, grok | SOL+XRP | +$822.1 | +$60.5 (5) \* | +$18.0 (13) | **Survived** |
| cw11-wk2 | gpt, grok | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | +$767.3 | +$506.1 (30) | +$619.8 (88) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw10-m301 | fable, gpt, qwen [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$1,023.9 | -$30.7 (10) | -$359.6 (43) \+ | Faded |
| cw10-m302 | fable, gpt, qwen [remap] | BNB+XRP | +$972.4 | -$66.1 (6) \* | -$592.9 (26) \+ | Faded |
| cw10-s1 | gpt [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$415.2 | -$430.5 (17) \+ | +$158.7 (33) | Faded |
| cw10-wk1 | fable, opus, gpt, gemini, qwen [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$528.8 | +$499.6 (17) | +$490.4 (37) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw10-wk2 | qwen, grok [remap] | BTC+ETH | +$176.5 | +$162.1 (18) | -$100.8 (85) \+ | Faded |
| cwq1-q1 | fable, opus, gpt, gemini [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$2,271.8 | +$451.1 (25) | -$123.8 (68) \+ | Faded |
| cwq1-q2 | fable, opus, deepseek, gemini [remap] | BNB+XRP | +$1,107.1 | +$333.2 (12) | +$172.2 (26) \+ | **Survived** |
| cwq1-s1 | gemini | SOL+XRP | +$1,491.0 | -$407.2 (35) \+ | -$610.7 (98) \+ | Faded |
| cw9-m301 | fable, opus, gpt, qwen, grok [remap] | BNB+XRP | +$797.6 | $0.0 (0) \* | -$276.0 (14) \+ | Faded |
| cw9-m302 | fable, opus, qwen, grok [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$784.9 | +$74.4 (2) \* | -$214.9 (22) \+ | Faded |
| cw9-s1 | gemini | SOL+XRP | +$266.9 | -$407.2 (35) \+ | -$610.7 (98) \+ | Faded |
| cw9-wk1 | deepseek, gemini, grok [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$250.4 | +$42.9 (35) \+ | -$561.6 (68) \+ | Faded |
| cw9-wk2 | opus, gpt, deepseek, gemini [remap] | BTC+ETH | +$216.9 | -$144.3 (16) | -$307.5 (36) \+ | Faded |
| cwm2-m1 | fable, opus, gemini, qwen [remap] | BNB+XRP | +$1,041.5 | -$29.9 (2) \* | -$286.7 (17) \+ | Faded |
| cwm2-m2 | fable, opus, gemini, qwen [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$1,021.7 | -$13.7 (2) \* | -$177.5 (20) | Faded |
| cwm2-s1 | gemini | SOL+XRP | +$923.2 | -$479.8 (34) \+ | -$561.1 (105) \+ | Faded |
| cw8-m301 | fable, opus, gemini, qwen [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$1,018.6 | -$13.7 (2) \* | -$177.5 (20) | Faded |
| cw8-m302 | fable, opus, gemini, qwen [remap] | BNB+XRP | +$943.0 | -$29.9 (2) \* | -$286.7 (17) \+ | Faded |
| cw8-s1 | gemini | BNB+XRP | +$445.4 | +$617.8 (60) | -$90.3 (140) \+ | Faded |
| cw8-wk1 | gpt, gemini, qwen [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$583.4 | +$271.2 (15) | -$629.8 (53) \+ | Faded |
| cw8-wk2 | gpt, gemini, qwen, grok [remap] | BNB+XRP | +$570.6 | +$1,044.4 (33) | +$852.2 (101) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw7-m301 | fable, gpt, gemini, qwen [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$1,351.8 | -$81.7 (27) \+ | -$579.7 (77) \+ | Faded |
| cw7-m302 | opus, gpt, gemini, qwen [remap] | BTC+ETH | +$528.4 | +$151.7 (4) \* | +$211.7 (6) \* | **Survived** |
| cw7-s1 | gemini | SOL+XRP | +$1,022.0 | -$14.6 (47) \+ | -$713.3 (100) \+ | Faded |
| cw7-wk1 | fable, opus, gpt, gemini [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$1,467.8 | +$451.1 (25) | -$123.8 (68) \+ | Faded |
| cw7-wk2 | fable, opus, gpt [remap] | BTC+ETH | +$953.2 | $0.0 (0) \* | -$49.0 (3) \* | Faded |
| cw6-m301 | opus, deepseek, gemini [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$1,793.8 | +$253.8 (21) | +$106.5 (71) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw6-m302 | gpt, deepseek, gemini, grok [remap] | BTC+ETH | +$547.8 | +$378.4 (9) \* | +$59.3 (28) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw6-s1 | grok [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$404.8 | +$423.3 (31) | +$61.9 (92) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw6-wk1 | opus, gpt, grok [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$609.5 | +$204.2 (13) | -$209.0 (42) \+ | Faded |
| cw6-wk2 | fable, opus, deepseek [remap] | BTC+ETH | +$135.4 | +$37.6 (3) \* | -$75.2 (16) \+ | Faded |
| cw5-m301 | fable, opus, gpt, gemini [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$1,717.1 | -$187.7 (4) \* \+ | +$282.1 (14) | Faded |
| cw5-s1 | gemini | BNB+XRP | +$178.7 | -$151.5 (36) \+ | -$116.7 (161) \+ | Faded |
| cw5-wk1 | gpt, gemini [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$510.4 | -$482.3 (59) \+ | -$594.3 (153) \+ | Faded |
| cw5-wk2 | fable, opus, gpt, gemini, grok [remap] | BTC+ETH | +$183.5 | +$71.9 (16) | -$147.4 (49) \+ | Faded |
| cw4-m301 | gpt, deepseek, gemini [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$1,676.0 | +$919.9 (9) \* | -$633.5 (5) \* \+ | Faded |
| cw4-m302 | fable, gpt, deepseek, gemini [remap] | BNB+XRP | +$1,155.2 | +$597.8 (8) \* | +$176.9 (16) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw4-s1 | deepseek | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | +$325.0 | +$506.2 (23) | +$597.2 (74) | **Survived** |
| cw4-wk1 | opus, deepseek, gemini, qwen [remap] | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | +$399.4 | +$141.5 (6) \* | +$130.3 (25) | **Survived** |
| cw4-wk2 | fable, deepseek, qwen | BNB+XRP | +$128.2 | -$318.7 (17) \+ | -$645.8 (71) \+ | Faded |
| cwm1-m1 | fable, gemini | SOL+XRP | +$1,618.4 | +$705.7 (8) \* | +$946.2 (22) \+ | **Survived** |
| cwm1-m2 | fable, gpt, deepseek, gemini, qwen [remap] | ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | +$756.6 | +$265.7 (10) | -$74.7 (27) \+ | Faded |
| cwm1-s1 | gemini | SOL+XRP | +$1,721.9 | +$1,069.6 (12) | +$682.2 (34) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw3-m301 | opus, deepseek, gemini [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$2,137.6 | +$79.0 (6) \* | +$387.0 (31) | **Survived** |
| cw3-m302 | fable, opus, deepseek, gemini, qwen [remap] | BTC+ETH | +$412.3 | +$3.1 (1) \* | -$334.2 (5) \* | Faded |
| cw3-s1 | gemini | SOL+XRP | +$1,604.3 | +$577.3 (54) \+ | +$562.0 (180) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw3-s2 | gemini | SOL+XRP | +$1,449.0 | +$1,069.6 (12) | +$682.2 (34) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw3-wk1 | opus, deepseek, gemini [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$2,175.1 | +$79.0 (6) \* | +$387.0 (31) | **Survived** |
| cw3-wk2 | opus, deepseek, gemini, grok [remap] | BTC+ETH | +$837.6 | +$18.1 (5) \* | -$298.7 (20) \+ | Faded |
| cw2-30d1 | opus, gpt, deepseek, gemini, qwen [remap] | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP [conc] | +$744.7 | +$719.3 (9) \* | +$534.7 (18) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw2-30d2 | opus, deepseek, gemini [remap] | ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP [conc] | +$655.1 | +$288.2 (7) \* \+ | +$133.3 (19) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw2-30d3 | opus, deepseek, gemini [remap] | BNB+XRP | +$489.1 | -$244.1 (2) \* | +$161.5 (12) \+ | Faded |
| cw2-30ds1 | gemini | BNB+XRP | +$383.8 | +$372.2 (10) | -$666.7 (15) \+ | Faded |
| cw2-7d1 | fable, opus, deepseek, gemini [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$299.1 | -$27.5 (4) \* \+ | -$45.2 (28) \+ | Faded |
| cw2-7d2 | gpt, deepseek, gemini, qwen [remap] | BNB+XRP | +$223.7 | +$323.9 (4) \* | -$58.0 (14) \+ | Faded |
| cw2-pt1 | fable, deepseek, grok [remap] | SOL | +$698.3 | +$20.3 (18) | -$614.0 (37) \+ | Faded |
| cw2-pt2 | opus [remap] | XRP | +$543.7 | +$438.5 (4) \* | -$589.9 (4) \* \+ | Faded |
| cw1-30d1 | fable, deepseek, opus, qwen [remap] | ETH+SOL | +$868.4 | -$37.9 (2) \* | -$398.8 (11) \+ | Faded |
| cw1-30d2 | gemini, gpt, deepseek [remap] | SOL+XRP+ETH | +$590.6 | +$637.6 (14) | +$583.9 (38) \+ | **Survived** |
| cw1-30d3 | fable, deepseek, opus, qwen [remap] | BTC+ETH+SOL | +$580.5 | -$85.0 (3) \* | -$345.8 (17) \+ | Faded |
| cw1-30ds1 | opus [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$442.8 | -$308.5 (26) \+ | -$616.8 (71) \+ | Faded |
| cw1-30ds2 | grok [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$262.9 | -$266.0 (22) \+ | -$589.4 (67) \+ | Faded |
| cw1-30ds3 | deepseek | XRP+BNB | +$119.0 | -$182.5 (33) \+ | -$469.0 (106) \+ | Faded |
| cw1-7d1 | fable, deepseek, opus, gpt [remap] | SOL+XRP | +$439.2 | +$6.0 (16) | -$73.1 (56) \+ | Faded |
| cw1-7d2 | fable, qwen, gemini, opus [remap] | XRP+BNB | +$429.5 | +$525.7 (44) | -$123.8 (76) \+ | Faded |
| cw1-7d3 | gpt, opus [remap] | BNB+XRP+SOL | +$398.6 | +$12.6 (26) | -$184.8 (76) \+ | Faded |
| cw1-7ds1 | gemini | XRP+BNB | +$417.8 | -$587.9 (47) \+ | -$584.0 (120) \+ | Faded |
| cw1-7ds2 | gpt [remap] | XRP+BNB | +$366.3 | -$375.3 (37) \+ | -$419.2 (126) \+ | Faded |
| cw1-7ds3 | qwen | XRP+BNB | +$267.0 | -$262.5 (28) \+ | -$203.0 (102) \+ | Faded |

*n in parentheses; \* = fewer than 10 closed trades (insufficient cell); \+ = non-zero skipped_nofunds (entries the engine could not fund -- the printed economics are then not the economics that ran). Home = the number the card's origin issue printed; the live presets have no home issue. [conc] = stake above this issue's cap for its universe size; [remap] = a superseded model id replayed on its lineage head (grok-4.5 / grok-4.6 -> grok-4.7, claude-opus-5 -> claude-opus-5.5, gpt-5.6-sol -> gpt-6.1-sol; none of the issue-14, Monthly-3, issue-13, issue-12 or issue-11 rows carries it). Verdict rule: Survived = net-positive on both fresh windows, Faded = net-negative on at least one. Survivors are tinted green. The 92 cards are 86 distinct configurations window aside (cwq1-q1 = cw7-wk1; cwq1-s1 = cw9-s1; cwm2-m1 = cw8-m302; cwm2-m2 = cw8-m301; cwm1-s1 = cw3-s2; cw3-m301 = cw3-wk1): the two rows of each pair carry the same WK and M30 numbers.*

**Counted:** 37 of 92 past cards **Survive** both fresh windows (issue #14 on its two windows: 24 of 87) -- by cohort 4 of 5 issue-14 cards, 3 of 3 Monthly-3 cards, 4 of 5 issue-13 cards, 3 of 5 issue-12 cards, 4 of 5 issue-11 cards, 1 of 5 issue-10 cards, 1 of 3 Quarterly-1 cards, 0 of 5 issue-9 cards, 0 of 3 Monthly-2 cards, 1 of 5 issue-8 cards, 1 of 5 issue-7 cards, 3 of 5 issue-6 cards, 0 of 4 issue-5 cards, 3 of 5 issue-4 cards, 2 of 3 Monthly-1 cards, 4 of 6 issue-3 cards, 2 of 8 issue-2 cards, 1 of 12 issue-1 cards. Taken a window at a time: 62 of 92 are positive on the week and 41 of 92 on the four weeks, and the two columns do not nest: a row can clear one and fail the other, so both windows remove cards. The survival curve by generation, each on its own first, second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth, seventh, eighth, ninth, tenth, eleventh, twelfth, thirteenth and fourteenth fresh week, reads: issue-1 50.0% -> 91.7% -> 8.3% -> 16.7% -> 25.0% -> 91.7% -> 8.3% -> 8.3% -> 0.0% -> 58.3% -> 50.0% -> 8.3% -> 16.7% -> **33.3%** now (4 of 12); issue-2 100.0% -> 50.0% -> 12.5% -> 25.0% -> 62.5% -> 75.0% -> 25.0% -> 25.0% -> 62.5% -> 0.0% -> 37.5% -> 62.5% -> **75.0%** now (6 of 8); issue-3 33.3% -> 33.3% -> 33.3% -> 83.3% -> 33.3% -> 33.3% -> 16.7% -> 66.7% -> 66.7% -> 16.7% -> 33.3% -> **100.0%** now (6 of 6); issue-4 20.0% -> 0.0% -> 80.0% -> 80.0% -> 60.0% -> 0.0% -> 80.0% -> 20.0% -> 40.0% -> 20.0% -> **80.0%** now (4 of 5); Monthly-1 66.7% -> 0.0% -> 33.3% -> 100.0% -> 66.7% -> 0.0% -> 66.7% -> 0.0% -> 0.0% -> 33.3% -> **100.0%** now (3 of 3); issue-5 25.0% -> 75.0% -> 50.0% -> 75.0% -> 0.0% -> 25.0% -> 100.0% -> 25.0% -> 25.0% -> **25.0%** now (1 of 4); issue-6 80.0% -> 40.0% -> 60.0% -> 0.0% -> 80.0% -> 40.0% -> 20.0% -> 80.0% -> **100.0%** now (5 of 5); issue-7 80.0% -> 80.0% -> 0.0% -> 40.0% -> 60.0% -> 40.0% -> 40.0% -> **40.0%** now (2 of 5); issue-8 40.0% -> 0.0% -> 60.0% -> 0.0% -> 0.0% -> 20.0% -> **60.0%** now (3 of 5); Monthly-2 100.0% -> 0.0% -> 0.0% -> 33.3% -> 0.0% -> 33.3% -> **0.0%** now (0 of 3); issue-9 0.0% -> 60.0% -> 20.0% -> 0.0% -> 60.0% -> **40.0%** now (2 of 5); Quarterly-1 33.3% -> 100.0% -> 33.3% -> 0.0% -> 66.7% -> **66.7%** now (2 of 3); issue-10 80.0% -> 40.0% -> 20.0% -> 40.0% -> **40.0%** now (2 of 5); issue-11 80.0% -> 60.0% -> 80.0% -> **100.0%** now (5 of 5); issue-12 20.0% -> 60.0% -> **100.0%** now (5 of 5); issue-13 60.0% -> **100.0%** now (5 of 5); Monthly-3 66.7% -> **100.0%** now (3 of 3); issue-14 **80.0%** now (4 of 5). Live presets: 1 of 4 Survive, 2 of 4 positive on the week, 1 of 4 on the month.

*The four live presets lead the table by standing rule. On the week: preset 4h4 -$55.9 on 2 closed, preset bc2 +$726.4 on 7 closed, preset sol -$238.3 on 6 closed, preset xrp +$874.7 on 4 closed -- 2 of the four net-positive. On the four-week window: preset 4h4 -$554.9 on 10 closed, preset bc2 +$308.1 on 18 closed, preset sol -$426.5 on 23 closed, preset xrp -$427.5 on 1 closed -- 1 of four. 1 Survives both. **sol** and **xrp** are marked [conc]: both run a $900 stake on a single coin, twice the $450 cap the stake table sets for a 1-coin universe, so their printed economics assume funding this issue's own rule would not grant. Passports for all four are in the open data (presets_recon_wk.json and presets_recon_night.json).*

***Origin re-runs (drift baseline).** Re-simulating the issue-14 cards on their OWN origin windows today lands within $0.0..$0.0 of the printed issue-14 numbers, the Monthly-3 cards within $0.0..$0.0 of theirs and the issue-13 cards within -$72.0..$0.0; 12 of the 13 re-runs reproduce to the cent. The widest deviation is cw13-s1 (+$250.8 printed, +$178.8 today) -- cards with positions still open when their origin window closed re-run to their settled result; issue #13 printed open positions for cw13-s1. Snapshot principle: no past issue is restated; the full drift table is in the open data (oos_walk_forward.drift_baseline).*

**Honest read.** The fresh search and its own back catalogue moved in the same direction this week. On the fresh week 62 of 92 past cards are net-positive -- issue #14 counted 39 of 87 on its own week -- and the ceiling of the fresh search moved to +$1,119.3 from +$538.1. On the fresh four weeks 41 of 92 are net-positive. Same replay machinery, same frozen knobs; what changed is the window and the size of the board. Three things keep this from being a statement about search. The board is not a fixed sample: it grows every issue and nothing is ever pruned, so a share computed on 92 cards is not comparable with one computed on 87 without saying which generations joined -- 5 of the 92 rows are new this issue. The month column is not clean evidence for four of the eighteen cohorts: it shares 21 of its 28 days with issue #14's own M30 window (shared stretch Oct 19-Nov 8), 14 of its 28 days with issue #13's own M30 window (shared stretch Oct 19-Nov 1), 7 of its 28 days with issue #12's own M30 window (shared stretch Oct 19-25) and 13 of its 28 days with Monthly Config Watch #3's calendar-October window (shared stretch Oct 19-31), so those cards are partly being scored on their own data. And the size of the in-sample number is not what decides the give-back on this board: the row that lost most on the week is cw1-7ds1 (-$587.9 on the week against +$417.8 printed at home), while the largest home number on the board, cwq1-q1 at +$2,271.8, made +$451.1. Fourteen fresh weeks of verdicts now: brutal, the opposite, split by window, the fourth, the fifth, the sixth, the seventh, the eighth, the ninth, the tenth, the eleventh, the twelfth, the thirteenth, and this one. That is a series of weathers, not a strategy.

---

## Calibrate axis: does TP/SL calibration help a config?

Matched pairs -- identical knobs, calibration OFF vs ON -- measured on net PnL. The table is the **whole stage-2 grid** of each window, and the **Both** row pools the two windows' pairs and nothing else. The board-leader slice is a second, separate measurement (19 WK pairs and 11 M30 pairs whose OFF or ON leg reached the top of a board); it is reported in the paragraph below and in the open data, and the two are never pooled together.

| Window | Pairs | Calibrate wins | Mean delta | Best delta | Worst delta |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| WK | 1,271 | 7.2% | -$218.3 | +$492.1 | -$1,080.8 |
| M30 | 1,280 | 32.3% | -$86.4 | +$1,593.9 | -$1,533.5 |
| **Both** | **2,551** | **19.8%** | **-$152.1** | **+$1,593.9** | **-$1,533.5** |

**The two windows answer the axis, and the whole-grid reading and the board-leader slice are separate measurements.** On the week calibration improves 7.2% of the 1,271 matched pairs (mean -$218.3, median -$183.1) and 6.4% of the 576 mature pairs (mean -$332.3); on the four weeks it improves 32.3% of 1,280 (mean -$86.4, median -$29.6) and 36.5% of the 820 mature pairs (mean -$132.0). Pooled over both windows the axis improves 19.8% of 2,551 pairs with a mean of -$152.1 -- a number that describes neither window on its own. The board-leader slices are separate: 0.0% of the 19 WK slice pairs improve (mean -$511.4, median -$425.0, OFF legs already at a median of +$1,066.7), and 27.3% of the 11 M30 slice pairs (mean -$226.1, OFF legs at +$1,243.1). Issue #14 measured a 20-pair WK slice (2 improving) and a 12-pair M30 slice (0). Where the axis reached the cards is visible above: 0 of the 2 published WK councils are calibrate=ON cells and 26 of the 61 WK finalists run it, while 0 of the 2 M30 cards are and 22 of the 53 M30 finalists do.

*The open-data pack also carries a 400-pair export (calibrate_effect) per collect. Its delta distribution is not the population's (median -$425.0 against the WK grid's -$183.1), so no claim in this section is computed from it; it is published for inspection only.*

---

## Secondary analysis -- solo-model top

**Sidebar to the council narrative.** Solo configs run inside the same pipeline and face the same gates: >=2 coins, the maturity gate for the window (>=15 closed on WK, >=20 on M30), one config per model.

### Solo top -- WK (Nov 9-16, 2026)

| # | Model | Coins | FH/TF | Net | Net % | maxDD | Trades | WR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| **#1** | gemini | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | 1d/1d,4h | **+$976.6** | +97.7% | 0.0% | 31 \* | 77.4% |
| **#2** | gpt | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | 1d/1d | **+$961.6** | +96.2% | 6.9% | 40 | 82.5% |

| # | Ladder | BE | Shifts | Conf filter | Source | Entry | Positional | Stake |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | 50:40,100:60 | on | TP -10 / SL +75 | >=60 (each) | farthest | 1/0 | reenter | $200 |
| #2 | 50:40,100:60 | on | TP -10 / SL +75 | >=60 (each) | farthest | 0/0 | reenter | $200 |

***2 solo cards on this window.** Both qualifying solos run the 5-coin table stake of $200. No single-coin row outranks them on the mature net board this issue; single-coin results are excluded from the cards by the >=2-coin rule either way and appear under Per-ticker bests. Source: summary_wk.json top_mature_by_window_branch.*

### Solo top -- M30 (Oct 19-Nov 16, 2026)

| # | Model | Coins | FH/TF | Net | Net % | maxDD | Trades | WR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| **#1** | gpt | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | **+$1,412.2** | +141.2% | 20.9% | 43 \* | 81.4% |
| **#2** | grok | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | **+$1,243.1** | +124.3% | 2.3% | 21 | 90.5% |

| # | Ladder | BE | Shifts | Conf filter | Source | Entry | Positional | Stake |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | 50:40,100:60 | on | TP -10 / SL +75 | >=60 (each) | median | 0/0 | reenter | $450 |
| #2 | 50:40,100:60 | on | TP -10 / SL +75 | >=60 (each) | median | 0/0 | reenter | $450 |

***Two solo cards on M30.** The mature solo board carries two models, gpt and grok, both on SOL+XRP, so the one-config-per-model rule admits two. Unfunded entries on the cards: #1 2, #2 0 (flagged \* on Trades); the best row on the board with 0 skips is gpt on SOL+XRP at +$1,302.8 on 45 closed. Source: top_mature_by_window_branch in the night collect.*

**OPEN IN SANDBOX**   **marketmania.ai/s/cw15-s1**

*Each link opens this exact frozen window; results visible without sign-in (embedded share signature). The codes are minted by the publish script before this file goes live; every card's full frozen query signature is in the open-data JSON next to its simulation index.*

**Council vs solo.** On the week the best solo sits below the best council (+$976.6 vs +$1,119.3 on the mature board, 31 closed against 64, 0.0% drawdown against 2.3%). On the four weeks the best solo sits below the best council (+$1,412.2 vs +$1,413.4, 43 closed against 39, 20.9% against 24.1%). Same in-sample caveats apply to both sides.

---

## Quality boards

Net PnL stays the primary board (continuity with issues #1-#14); four selection views sit on top of it at zero additional simulations. **Calmar-like** = net / max(maxDD, 1.0), positive net only; **WR board** = win rate among mature configs (>=15 closed on WK, >=20 on M30); **Smoothness** = R2 of a linear fit through the daily closed-equity series, mature rows with net > 0 and at least 5 days, ties broken by ulcer index; **Quality composite** = mean rank over net, Calmar-like, win rate and R2, lower is better. Top-3 of each board on each window below; all 15 rows of all eight boards are in the open-data JSON.

| Board | Config | Coins | FH/TF | Net | WR | maxDD | Cls | R2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| WK Calmar | gpt, gemini | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | 1d/1d | +$1,066.7 | 77.1% | 0.0% | 35 | 0.929 |
| WK Calmar | gpt, gemini | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | 1d/1d | +$1,066.7 | 77.1% | 0.0% | 35 | 0.929 |
| WK Calmar | fable, gpt, gemini | SOL+XRP | 4h/4h,1h | +$1,050.6 | 94.4% | 0.0% | 18 | 0.860 |
| WK WR | gemini, gpt, deepseek | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | 1d/1d | +$754.3 | 100.0% | 0.0% | 21 | 0.965 |
| WK WR | gpt, deepseek [cal] | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | 1d/1d | +$682.2 | 100.0% | 0.0% | 29 | 0.972 |
| WK WR | gpt, deepseek [cal] | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | 1d/1d | +$682.2 | 100.0% | 0.0% | 29 | 0.972 |
| WK Smoothness | deepseek, grok | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | 1d/1d | +$604.0 | 89.5% | 0.0% | 19 | 0.993 |
| WK Smoothness | grok | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | 1d/1d | +$762.7 | 88.9% | 0.0% | 27 | 0.990 |
| WK Smoothness | grok | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | 1d/1d | +$762.7 | 88.9% | 0.0% | 27 | 0.990 |
| WK Quality | gemini, gpt, deepseek | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | 1d/1d | +$754.3 | 100.0% | 0.0% | 21 | 0.965 |
| WK Quality | gpt, gemini, grok [cal] | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | 1d/1d | +$738.6 | 96.9% | 0.0% | 32 | 0.967 |
| WK Quality | gpt, gemini [cal] | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP | 1d/1d,4h | +$752.1 | 94.1% | 0.0% | 34 | 0.969 |
| M30 Calmar | gpt, deepseek, gemini [cal] | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | +$1,030.2 | 96.0% | 0.3% | 25 | 0.966 |
| M30 Calmar | grok [cal] | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | +$1,026.2 | 100.0% | 0.0% | 21 | 0.959 |
| M30 Calmar | grok [cal] | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | +$1,026.2 | 100.0% | 0.0% | 21 | 0.959 |
| M30 WR | grok [cal] | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | +$1,026.2 | 100.0% | 0.0% | 21 | 0.959 |
| M30 WR | grok [cal] | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | +$1,026.2 | 100.0% | 0.0% | 21 | 0.959 |
| M30 WR | gpt | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB | 1d/4h | +$652.1 | 100.0% | 0.0% | 25 | 0.960 |
| M30 Smoothness | gpt, gemini | SOL | 1d/1d,4h | +$956.0 | 75.0% | 9.8% | 20 | 0.971 |
| M30 Smoothness | fable, gemini [cal] | SOL+XRP | 4h/4h | +$264.9 | 91.7% | 1.3% | 24 | 0.969 |
| M30 Smoothness | gpt | SOL | 1d/1d,4h | +$965.0 | 79.2% | 13.1% | 24 | 0.969 |
| M30 Quality | gpt, deepseek, gemini [cal] | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | +$1,030.2 | 96.0% | 0.3% | 25 | 0.966 |
| M30 Quality | grok [cal] | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | +$1,026.2 | 100.0% | 0.0% | 21 | 0.959 |
| M30 Quality | grok [cal] | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | +$1,026.2 | 100.0% | 0.0% | 21 | 0.959 |

*[cal] = calibrate=ON cell; the board column names the window. Both Calmar boards are degenerate by construction -- their top rows sit at 0.0% (WK) and 0.3% (M30) maxDD, so the score collapses onto net PnL; read them as 'net among configs that barely drew down'. The Smoothness boards are the ones that can leave a window's dominant universe, and this issue only the M30 board does: the WK board's top row is a BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP config at R2 0.993 on a net of +$604.0, the M30 board's a SOL config at R2 0.971 on +$956.0; the WK row sits inside the universe the WK mature net top-10 leans on (BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP). That trade -- straightness bought with size -- is exactly what the board exists to expose. The M30 boards are drawn from a mature pool of 2,941 configs against 1,981 on WK, because four weeks clear a >=20-trade gate that one week does not.*

***Stability, and what it is across this issue.** The board is defined as **mature net top-40 on BOTH windows** of the run that computes it. The run that produced it here is the night collect, whose two windows are **WK and M30** -- the same two windows this issue prints, computed in a second execution of the WK plan -- so this issue's board reads **stable across WK and M30**. **5 configurations qualify.** 4 of them BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP (1 BNB+XRP), 1 councils and 0 clean (zero unfunded entries on both windows); the top three by rank sum are council gemini, grok; solo gpt; solo gpt. The shared board is narrower than either window's own: 13 of the 20 rows exported from its WK board are BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP; 19 of the 20 rows exported from its M30 board are SOL+XRP, and no row exported from one window's mature board appears on the other's. The count is not comparable with issue #4's 25 (its board was measured across M30 and the calendar month); the boards measured across WK and M30 were issue #14's, at 4, issue #13's, at 0, issue #12's, at 1, issue #11's, at 0, issue #10's, at 4, issue #9's, at 7, issue #8's, at 4, issue #7's, at 16, issue #6's, at 9, issue #5's, at 0, and issue #3's, at 21. Full list in the open data (stability).*

---

## Hand-tuned baseline vs the grid

Standing section, twelfth issue. One hand-tuned configuration is treated as the reference the search has to beat -- not on net PnL, where any large search wins by construction, but on the three properties a configuration is actually tuned for: **win rate, shallow drawdown and a straight equity line**. The reference (referred to below as the **hand-tuned anchor**) is the live preset 1d_3_llm_BC2_v02, a 3-model 1d council on SOL+XRP at the $450 two-coin stake; it is distinct from the pre-search hand-tuned set A/B/C carried in Baselines below. Its replay row is in the walk-forward table above; here it is the yardstick.

**Beat rule (frozen with the criteria):** a config beats the anchor only if it does so on all three at once -- win rate higher, maxDD lower and smoothness R2 higher -- among mature, non-concentrated search rows. Net PnL is not part of the rule; it is reported next to the winners so the cost of the improvement is visible.

**The anchor on each window**

| Window | Config | Coins | FH/TF | Net | WR | maxDD | R2 | Ulcer | Cls |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| WK | **Hand-tuned anchor (1d_3_llm_BC2_v02)** | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | +$726.4 | 100.0% | 0.0% | 0.981 | 0.00 | 7 |
| M30 | **Hand-tuned anchor (1d_3_llm_BC2_v02)** | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | +$308.1 | 77.8% | 52.8% | 0.499 | 21.31 | 18 |

**0 of the 1,981 mature WK configs (0.0%) clear all three bars at once, and 285 of the 2,941 mature M30 configs (9.7%).** The anchor's own two windows are different rows: on the week +$726.4 net at 100.0% win rate with a 0.0% drawdown, an R2 of 0.981 and 7 closed trades; on the four weeks +$308.1 at 77.8%, a 52.8% drawdown, an R2 of 0.499 and 18 closed. The week row is thin against the >=15 gate the search rows must pass (the anchor is exempt from that gate by construction: it is the reference, not a candidate). Read against net PnL, no WK config clears all three bars, so there is no net comparison to make on that window; all 10 of the 10 best M30 winners by net also beat it on net PnL. The share itself moves with the window (0.0% of the WK field, 9.7% of the M30 field), so read it as one field at a time, not as a property of the anchor.

*No WK table here: 0 of the 1,981 mature WK configs clear all three bars at once, so there is no top-10 to rank. The anchor's own WK row sets the bars at a 100.0% win rate, a 0.0% maxDD and a smoothness R2 of 0.981 on 7 closed trades, and no mature WK row is above it on all three at the same time.*

**Top-5 by net among the 285 M30 configs that beat the anchor on win rate, maxDD and smoothness at once**

| # | Config | Coins | FH/TF | Stake | Net | WR | maxDD | R2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | gpt | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | $450 | +$1,412.2 | 81.4% | 20.9% | 0.875 |
| #2 | gpt | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | $450 | +$1,412.2 | 81.4% | 20.9% | 0.875 |
| #3 | gpt [cal] | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | $450 | +$1,317.4 | 88.4% | 21.8% | 0.846 |
| #4 | gpt [cal] | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | $450 | +$1,317.4 | 88.4% | 21.8% | 0.846 |
| #5 | gpt | SOL+XRP | 1d/1d | $375 | +$1,302.8 | 82.2% | 17.4% | 0.903 |

*Anchor passport (verbatim, as stored): members=gemini-3.1-pro,gpt-6.1-sol,deepseek-v4-pro tokens=SOL,XRP fh=1d tf=1d conf_mode=each min_conf=60 max_sideways=2 max_diff_side=0 tp_sl_source=nearest trade_mode=position same_side=update opposite=reverse no_signal=hold time_stop=3x steps=40:80,100:20 steps_on=1 be=1 tp_shift=30 sl_shift=50 deposit=1000 lev=10 refill=0 stake=450 calibrate=- variant=v0*

---

## Per-ticker bests

Which coin was extractable this window, and by what. Single-coin results are excluded from the council cards by rule (idiosyncratic-coin risk) and reported here, never ranked against the cards. The dedicated per-coin branch contributed 540 + 1,125 sims -- a compacted grid, one best per coin per window; the branch tag in brackets says which kind won.

### WK (Nov 9-16, 2026)

| Coin | Best config (branch) | FH/TF | Net (trades) |
|---|---|---|---|
| BTC | gemini [solo] | 4h/4h | +$528.5 (21) |
| ETH | gpt, gemini, grok [council] | 1d/1d | +$608.7 (6) \* |
| SOL | opus, gpt, gemini [council] | 4h/4h | +$611.7 (24) |
| BNB | deepseek, gemini [council] | 4h/4h | +$523.1 (30) |
| XRP | gemini, grok [council] | 4h/4h | +$612.5 (24) |

### M30 (Oct 19-Nov 16, 2026)

| Coin | Best config (branch) | FH/TF | Net (trades) |
|---|---|---|---|
| BTC | grok [solo] | 1d/1d,4h | +$405.5 (16) |
| ETH | gpt [solo] | 1d/1d,4h | +$733.0 (27) |
| SOL | gpt [solo] | 1d/1d | +$1,173.1 (24) |
| BNB | gemini [solo] | 4h/4h,1h | +$656.9 (35) |
| XRP | gemini, grok [council] | 4h/4h | +$890.6 (85) |

*n in parentheses; \* = fewer than 10 closed trades (thin -- direction only). 0 of the ten winners run calibrate ON; 4 of the five WK winners and 1 of the five M30 winners are councils.*

**The reads.** On the week XRP leads at +$612.5 and 1 of the five rows is thin -- 6 to 30 closed trades against a 15-trade gate. On the four weeks no row is thin: 16 to 85 closed, SOL leading at +$1,173.1, and no one coin leads both windows. The 1d horizon wins 1 of the five WK coins and 3 of the five M30 coins. **Winner's curse applies to this whole table**: each row is the maximum of a per-coin grid, biased high by selection alone, and none has an out-of-sample read until next issue.

---

## Baselines

Three independent reference points, none of them search output, re-simulated fresh on both of this issue's frozen windows inside the same two collects (engine 1.1): the engine solo default for each of the 7 models, the default council-of-7, and the pre-search hand-tuned set A/B/C carried since issue #1. The tables show the universe-aware **table-stake** run -- this issue's canonical mode ($200 for the 5-coin defaults; A and B already at their $300 3-coin cap; C moves $400 -> $450 on 2 coins) -- with the best and worst of the seven solo defaults on each window; all eleven rows per window and both stake modes are in the open data.

### WK (Nov 9-16, 2026)

| Baseline | Net PnL | Trades | WR | maxDD |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best solo default (gpt-6.1-sol) | -$24.1 \* | 348 | 66% | 5.0% |
| Worst solo default (grok-4.7) | -$82.8 \* | 385 | 57% | 8.3% |
| Council-of-7 default | -$51.9 \* | 132 | 54% | 5.2% |
| **Hand-tuned config A (pre-search)** | +$800.0 | 11 | 100% | 0.0% |
| **Hand-tuned config B (pre-search)** | +$203.6 | 27 | 74% | 9.8% |
| **Hand-tuned config C (pre-search)** | -$37.9 | 2 | 50% | 10.2% |

### M30 (Oct 19-Nov 16, 2026)

| Baseline | Net PnL | Trades | WR | maxDD |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best solo default (gpt-6.1-sol) | -$118.1 \* | 1113 | 65% | 15.5% |
| Worst solo default (grok-4.7) | -$243.9 \* | 1098 | 59% | 24.4% |
| Council-of-7 default | -$88.2 \* | 553 | 63% | 9.2% |
| **Hand-tuned config A (pre-search)** | +$604.9 \* | 31 | 77% | 30.6% |
| **Hand-tuned config B (pre-search)** | -$181.4 \* | 81 | 60% | 46.6% |
| **Hand-tuned config C (pre-search)** | -$398.8 \* | 11 | 36% | 48.2% |

*\* = non-zero skipped_nofunds at table stake. On the 5-coin defaults those counts are the stake table doing its job: at $200 a $1,000 deposit funds at most five concurrent positions while the defaults fire hundreds of entries per window (77 to 261 skipped each on the week, 463 to 1,228 on the four weeks). The other five solo defaults run between the two printed rows on each window. **The conclusions do not change between modes**: on WK they do so for every row, and on M30 they do so for every row. 2 of the three hand-tuned configs are already at their own table cap, so their two modes are identical on both windows. Source: baselines_wk.json (22 sims) and baselines_night.json (44 sims, of which 22 are the M30 half), inside this issue's two collects.*

**Every engine default lost money on both windows; the hand-tuned set split on both windows.** On WK the seven solo defaults run -$24.1 to -$82.8 at table stake, the council-of-7 -$51.9, and the three hand-tuned configs A +$800.0, B +$203.6, C -$37.9 -- 2 of the three positive. On M30 the defaults run -$118.1 to -$243.9 solo (council-of-7 -$88.2) and the three hand-tuned configs A +$604.9, B -$181.4, C -$398.8 -- 1 of the three positive. The upper half of the standing ordering (search > hand-tuned > defaults) holds on both windows, in-sample as ever -- the fresh search makes +$1,119.3 on the week against a best baseline of +$800.0, and +$1,413.4 on the four weeks against +$604.9. The live presets are a separate row of evidence: 2 of the four are net-positive on the week and 1 of four on the month (walk-forward table above), and 2 of them run stakes above this issue's cap.

### Live presets & preset neighbourhoods

Four hand-tuned configurations trade live on the platform (not search output, distinct from the pre-search A/B/C set): preset bc2 = '1d_3_llm_BC2_v02'; preset 4h4 = '4h_4_llm_v02'; preset sol = 'Sol'; preset xrp = 'XRP'. Their replay rows lead the walk-forward table; passports and window detail are in the open data (presets_recon_wk.json and presets_recon_night.json). The neighbourhood grid asks a narrower question: does a one-knob neighbour beat the preset as configured? Two of the four have a local grid this issue (53 cells per window); the two single-coin presets do not (0 cells -- the local grid is not built for them, so no neighbour claim is made about either).

| Live preset | Window | As configured | Best neighbour in local grid | Cells | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| preset bc2 | WK | +$726.4 | +$1,186.4 (1d/1d, SOL+XRP, 5 cls) | 34 | neighbour +$460.0 |
| preset bc2 | M30 | +$308.1 | +$1,244.2 (1d/4h, SOL+XRP, 32 cls) | 34 | neighbour +$936.2 |
| preset 4h4 | WK | -$55.9 | +$198.9 (1d/1d, ETH+SOL, 2 cls) | 19 | neighbour +$254.8 |
| preset 4h4 | M30 | -$554.9 | +$198.9 (1d/1d, ETH+SOL, 2 cls) | 19 | neighbour +$753.8 |

In **4 of the 4** preset-window cells with a grid, a one-knob neighbour beat the configuration as it is actually running. The largest single edit is preset bc2's 1d/1d -> 1d/4h horizon move on M30, which turns +$308.1 into +$1,244.2. The presets are not at a local optimum -- a testable, low-risk edit, unlike adopting a search champion wholesale. Cell counts are small (34 and 19 per window) and every neighbour is an in-sample maximum of its own little grid.

---

## Patterns: what the finalists look like

Knob modes across each window's unique finalists (mature net top-10 per branch plus all four quality boards, deduplicated by full signature; 61 unique configs on WK, 44 of them councils; 53 on M30, 25 councils).

| Knob | WK finalists mode | M30 finalists mode |
|---|---|---|
| Forecast horizon | 1d (52/61) | 1d (51/53) |
| Ladder shape (steps) | 50:40,100:60 (58/61) | 50:40,100:60 (50/53) |
| Break-even stop (BE) | on (61/61) | on (53/53) |
| Min confidence | 60 (61/61) | 60 (44/53) |
| SL shift | 75 (58/61) | 75 (50/53) |
| TP shift | -10 (58/61) | -10 (50/53) |
| TP/SL source | farthest (51/61) | farthest (35/53) |
| Calibrate ON | 26/61 | 22/53 |
| Universe | BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP (49/61) | SOL+XRP (38/53) |

The mechanical core is the same on both windows and unchanged for the fifteenth issue running: 50:40,100:60 ladder, break-even on, conf 60, SL +75 / TP -10, farthest source. The horizon is **1d** on WK (52/61) and **1d** on M30 (51/53). **Calibrate=ON** runs in 26 of 61 WK finalists against 22 of 53 on M30, where issue #14 measured 9/53 on its week and 29/53 on its month. The universe: BTC+ETH+SOL+BNB+XRP takes 49 of the 61 WK finalists while SOL+XRP takes 38 of the 53 M30 finalists. Membership concentrates too -- gpt leads the WK council finalists (34 of 44) and gpt the M30 ones (23 of 25). Standing caveats: refinement seeds from the same grid winners, so part of the convergence is search-design echo; and a knob core that produced 24-of-87 survival one issue ago and 37-of-92 this issue is describing the weather, not a recommendation.

---

## Liquidation note

Liquidation is modeled by the engine at the fixed 10x leverage used throughout. Across the published cards, stop-loss placement stays inside the distance that would approach the liquidation threshold; maxDD is printed on every config so realized risk is visible directly. This issue the published cards draw down 2.3% and 0.0% on the week and 24.1% and 41.6% on the month, and the replay table is deeper: 10 replayed rows drew down more than 40% on the week and 49 on the month, 1 and 35 of them past 55%. A high headline net and a survivable path are different claims, and so are a shallow in-sample drawdown and a shallow one next week.

---

## Watch amendments (this issue)

> **Amendment 3 (standing) -- smoothness and a quality composite.** Every simulation stores its daily closed-equity series and the three numbers read off it (n_days, smooth_r2, ulcer); the smoothness board ranks mature rows with net > 0 and at least 5 days by R2 with ulcer as tie-break, and the quality composite ranks by the mean of the net, Calmar-like, win-rate and R2 ranks. Both still cost zero additional simulations and the headline board is still net PnL.

> **Amendment 4 (standing) -- the monthly split.** The weekly Config Watch keeps two windows, the calendar week (WK) and the four calendar weeks that end at the same edge (M30, Oct 19-Nov 16, 2026); the calendar-month board belongs to the Monthly Config Watch line and no calendar-month number is printed in a weekly issue. This issue's night collect computes no calendar-month window at all: calendar October belongs to Monthly Config Watch #3, published Nov 5, and Q3 2026 to Quarterly Config Watch #1, published Oct 9, whose 3 cards are on the walk-forward table here.

> **Amendment 5 (standing) -- the standing OOS board grows with every issue.** Every card this series publishes joins the walk-forward table and is never removed: this issue replays **92 cards** -- issue #14's 5 join Monthly Config Watch #3's 3, issue #13's 5, issue #12's 5, issue #11's 5, issue #10's 5, Quarterly Config Watch #1's 3, issue #9's 5, Monthly Config Watch #2's 3, issue #8's 5, issue #7's 5, issue #6's 5, issue #5's 4, issue #4's 5, Monthly Config Watch #1's 3 and issues #1, #2 and #3's 26 -- plus the four live presets, on both fresh windows. **Monthly and quarterly cards are judged by the weekly rule** (net-positive on both of this issue's fresh windows), the same rule every other row is judged by; their own calendar-month or calendar-quarter origin window is the Home column and nothing else. One consequence for the counts: a survival share is computed on a board that changes size every issue, so it is reported with the cohort breakdown beside it and never as a trend on its own. **Stability** is defined inside the run that computes it: this issue's night collect computes WK and M30, so the board reads across WK and M30 -- the issue-#3 definition, the one issues #5, #6, #7, #8, #9, #10, #11, #12, #13 and #14 used as well -- where issue #4's read across M30 and the calendar month. 

All three amendments are standing, provisional and scoped to this series. **Formalization is slated for methodology v1.2**; until then this issue runs on v1.1 plus the Config Watch amendments approved 12.08 (hash e66c7e8c864a2233).

---

## Limitations

- **Two windows, one regime, and they overlap.** M30 (Oct 19-Nov 16, 2026) contains WK (Nov 9-16, 2026) -- 7 of the week's 7 days are inside it -- and it shares 21 of its 28 days with issue #14's own M30 window (shared stretch Oct 19-Nov 8), 14 of its 28 days with issue #13's own M30 window (shared stretch Oct 19-Nov 1), 7 of its 28 days with issue #12's own M30 window (shared stretch Oct 19-25) and 13 of its 28 days with Monthly Config Watch #3's calendar-October window (shared stretch Oct 19-31). The two columns of this issue are therefore not two independent tests: agreement between them is partly arithmetic, and for the issue-14, issue-13, issue-12 and Monthly-3 cohorts the M30 replay column is decay context rather than pure out-of-sample. Do not read them as a cross-validation.
- **The two windows come from two collects, and the two runs of the same week agree on the ceiling, not on the whole grid.** WK is the weekly run (generated 2026-11-18T10:35:13Z), M30 the night run (generated 2026-11-18T14:07:10Z), which recomputed the same WK week in the same pass on its own grid: the night run ranks a different mature WK top-10 (9 of its 10 rows in common, the same top row), so its WK ceiling is the same +$1,119.3 (fable, gpt, gemini on SOL+XRP), but its WK grid median is +$62.4 against the weekly collect's +$62.7, its WK Smoothness leader is R2 0.993 on +$604.0 against R2 0.993 on +$604.0, and 0 of 1,958 mature WK rows beat the anchor there against 0 of 1,981 here. Every WK number this issue prints is the weekly collect's; the night run's WK half is used only for the cross-window stability board. Same engine, same criteria, same collect code, but not the same execution -- a number is comparable across the two windows only as far as that is.
- **Stability is defined inside the run that computes it.** The board comes from the night run, whose two windows are WK and M30, so it reads across those two -- and 5 configurations are in the mature net top-40 of both. Issue #14 read the same pair one week earlier and held 4, issue #13 the week before that held 0, issue #12 1, issue #11 0, issue #10 4, issue #9 7, issue #8 4, issue #7 16, issue #6 9, issue #5 0 and issue #3's board (the other one across the same pair) held 21; issue #4's 25 is not comparable at all, having been measured across M30 and the calendar month. A board this size is one observation per issue and no claim is made from a single reading.
- **Both windows lie after the model cutover.** The cutover at Oct 17, 2026 09:01 UTC lies two days before M30's left edge (Oct 19), so WK and M30 read the successor builds only -- the first issue since #10 whose windows hold no cutover day (issue #10's lay wholly before it); the lineage probes count 7 raw model ids on WK and 7 on M30, one per line. Every published card that named a superseded id is replayed on the lineage head ([remap] rows: 57 of the 96 rows -- 53 of the 92 cards (by cohort issue-10 5 of 5, Quarterly-1 2 of 3, issue-9 4 of 5, Monthly-2 2 of 3, issue-8 4 of 5, issue-7 4 of 5, issue-6 5 of 5, issue-5 3 of 4, issue-4 3 of 5, Monthly-1 1 of 3, issue-3 4 of 6, issue-2 7 of 8 and issue-1 9 of 12) and all four live presets), and a remapped replay is not the same simulation the origin issue ran. The grok 4.5 -> 4.6 cutover of 2026-08-24 lies entirely before both windows.
- **The cutover hours.** The two roll-out slots of Oct 17 (07:01 and 08:01 UTC; invalid rows for the three superseded ids, council of four in those hours) fall outside the M30 window and outside the WK week.
- **Calibrated replays are pinned to their origin point.** 17 replay rows carry calibrate=1 with the calibration point fixed in their stored query (calibrate_asof: 2026-08-25, 2026-09-01, 2026-09-07, 2026-09-14, 2026-09-15, 2026-09-21, 2026-10-01, 2026-10-06, 2026-10-20, 2026-10-26, 2026-11-02, 2026-11-03), so their TP/SL multipliers are the ones in force when the origin issue was computed -- including the cards signed with the pinned date at publication: issue-12 cw12-wk2 (Oct 26, 2026), issue-13 cw13-m302 and cw13-wk1 (Nov 2, 2026) and Monthly-3 cwm3-m1 and cwm3-m2 (Nov 3, 2026); up to issue #11 a calibrated replay used the live point of the day it ran. The rows: cw11-m302, cw12-wk2, cw13-m302, cw13-wk1, cw3-m302, cw4-wk2, cw5-wk1, cw5-wk2, cw6-m302, cw6-wk2, cw7-m302, cw9-wk2, cwm1-m2, cwm2-s1, cwm3-m1, cwm3-m2, cwq1-q2. For the twelve older rows the week-over-issue trajectory changed method once, at issue #12.
- **Concentrated rows are published, not hidden.** 4 rows run stakes above this issue's cap for their universe size and are marked [conc] (preset_sol, preset_xrp, cw2-30d1, cw2-30d2); their printed economics assume funding the current rule would not grant. They stay in the table because removing them would flatter the preset row.
- **The stake rule changes what runs, not only its size.** Capping the stake changes WHICH entries get funded: the seven table-stake solo defaults skip 77 to 261 entries each, and 21 replay rows carry unfunded entries (up to 23 on cw1-7ds1). Where skipped_nofunds is non-zero the printed economics are not the economics that ran; the rows are flagged, never silently pooled.
- **Snapshot principle.** This report is a frozen snapshot taken at the generated-at timestamps; numbers are not updated retroactively and past issues are not restated. The drift baseline exists because a re-run does not reproduce every past number; the widest this issue (cw13-s1: +$250.8 printed, +$178.8 today) is a card with positions still open when its origin window closed, and such a card re-runs to its settled result.
- **Research-to-date counter is pinned.** The counter below is pinned from wave 3 onward and is read at the Nov 16, 2026 16:00 UTC cut-off; issue #14 printed 87,760 resolved and 74 published reports against 93,429 and 78 here. The model line keeps the definition issue #4 introduced (7 tracked, current line-up; earlier versions folded into their successors' lineage), so the twelve issues' model counts are comparable and issue #3's is not.
- **No calendar month in this issue.** The night collect computes M30 and WK and nothing else, so no claim about a calendar month is made anywhere here. Monthly Config Watch #3 published Nov 5 and Quarterly Config Watch #1 Oct 9; calendar November belongs to Monthly Config Watch #4. Monthly Config Watch #3's 3 cards, Quarterly Config Watch #1's 3, Monthly Config Watch #2's 3 and Monthly Config Watch #1's 3 appear in this issue only as replay rows, judged by the weekly rule.
- **Provider incident inside the windows.** Weekly Model Watch #14 records a provider incident inside M30: on Nov 5, 46 of qwen-3.8-max's 210 forecasts were rejected by the provider (input-moderation error) and are absent from the slots every replay on M30 reads; 2 forecasts on Nov 7 were produced without the news block. Weekly Model Watch #15 records that grok-4.7 returned no valid answer for 13 of its 1,470 forecasts inside WK and M30 (8 on Nov 9, 3 on Nov 10, 1 on Nov 11, 1 on Nov 15); those rows are absent from the slots every replay reads; 4 qwen-3.8-max forecasts in the same week were produced without the news block.
- **Multiple testing.** 15,727 simulations across the two collects (5,250 weekly + 10,477 night); at this scale some winners are expected from chance alone. Antidotes: axes frozen before launch, the walk-forward table, independent baselines, in-sample labeling. No formal correction yet.
- **Winner's curse and thin cells.** Every card, board row and per-ticker best is the maximum of a search, biased high by selection alone. On the week the per-ticker winners closed 6-30 trades and 38 of the 96 replay rows are under 10 closed; on the four weeks 7 replay rows are thin and 0 per-ticker winners are. Flagged with \*, reported for completeness.
- Research output, not financial advice.

---

## Counters & lineage

**Weekly collect (WK window)**

| Stage | Sims |
|---|---|
| Scan (s1) | 476 |
| Systematic grid (s2) | 3,824 |
| Refinement: ladder + stake sweep (s2b+s3b) | 121 |
| Preset neighbourhood grid (s2p) | 53 |
| Per-ticker probes (s5t) | 60 |
| Dedicated per-ticker (s6t+s6tc) | 540 |
| OOS replays (s4cw14+s4cw14o+s4cw13+s4cw13o+s4cwm3+s4cwm3o+s4cw12+s4cw12o+s4cw11+s4cw11o+s4cw10+s4cw10o+s4cwq1+s4cwq1o+s4cw9+s4cw9o+s4cwm2+s4cwm2o+s4cw8+s4cw8o+s4cw7+s4cw7o+s4cw6+s4cw6o+s4cw5+s4cw5o+s4cw4+s4cw4o+s4cwm1+s4cwm1o+s4cw3+s4cw3o+s4cw2+s4cw2o+s4cw1+s4pre) | 176 |
| **Total** | **5,250** |
| Errors / zero-trade | 0 / 1,090 |
| Engine | 1.1 |

**Night collect (M30 and a second execution of the WK week; this issue publishes M30 from it, and its WK half feeds the cross-window stability board only)**

| Stage | Sims |
|---|---|
| Scan (s1) | 952 |
| Systematic grid (s2) | 7,648 |
| Refinement: ladder + stake sweep (s2b+s3b) | 245 |
| Preset neighbourhood grid (s2p) | 106 |
| Per-ticker probes (s5t) | 129 |
| Dedicated per-ticker (s6t+s6tc) | 1,125 |
| OOS replays (s4cw14+s4cw14o+s4cw13+s4cw13o+s4cwm3+s4cwm3o+s4cw12+s4cw12o+s4cw11+s4cw11o+s4cw10+s4cw10o+s4cwq1+s4cwq1o+s4cw9+s4cw9o+s4cwm2+s4cwm2o+s4cw8+s4cw8o+s4cw7+s4cw7o+s4cw6+s4cw6o+s4cw5+s4cw5o+s4cw4+s4cw4o+s4cwm1+s4cwm1o+s4cw3+s4cw3o+s4cw2+s4cw2o+s4cw1+s4pre) | 272 |
| **Total** | **10,477** |
| Errors / zero-trade | 0 / 1,929 |
| Engine | 1.1 |

***Scale note (vs issue #14).** Issue #14 ran 15,952 sims over two windows in two collects; issue #15 runs 15,727 over two windows in two -- 5,250 in the weekly collect (WK) and 10,477 in the night collect (M30 and the same WK week together). The per-window grid is close to unchanged: 3,824 WK cells and 3,824 M30 cells here against 4,048 WK and 3,856 M30 cells there. The per-coin branch is 540 and 1,125 against 555 and 1,085. The replay branch grew in rows (96 configs against 91) and in sims (176 and 272 against 166 and 257), because one more cohort joined and every row is replayed on every window of its collect. The two selection boards still cost zero simulations.*

***No extras pass in either collect.** Equity series, the grid histograms (0 extra sims), the baselines and the calibrate packs are produced by the same two collects that wrote the boards. The baseline runs are verification, outside both search totals: 22 sims on WK (11 configs x 2 stake modes) and 44 in the night collect, of which the 22 M30 rows belong to this issue. 0 equity replays were needed. **Model lines in these windows.** Seven lines, one raw id each in both windows; the three lineage heads carry no old-id row, the cutover of Oct 17, 2026 09:01 UTC lying before M30: claude-opus-5.5 -- WK: 1,470 rows, M30: 5,880 rows, all under claude-opus-5.5 from each window's first slot (succession claude-opus-5, claude-opus-4.8); gpt-6.1-sol -- WK: 1,470 rows, M30: 5,880 rows, all under gpt-6.1-sol from each window's first slot (succession gpt-5.6-sol); grok-4.7 -- WK: 1,470 rows, M30: 5,880 rows, all under grok-4.7 from each window's first slot (succession grok-4.6, grok-4.5). The other four lines (claude-fable-5, deepseek-v4-pro, gemini-3.1-pro, qwen-3.8-max) carry one id each.*

Generated at: 2026-11-18T10:35:13Z (weekly collect) and 2026-11-18T14:07:10Z (night collect)  ·  Methodology v1.1 + Config Watch amendments (approved 12.08), hash e66c7e8c864a2233.

**Snapshot principle:** this report is a frozen snapshot of the search taken at the generated-at timestamps above; numbers are not updated retroactively. Each issue re-runs the pipeline fresh over that issue's windows.

---

## Research to date

> **RESEARCH SNAPSHOT** -- THIS REPORT -- search effort: **15,727 simulations** (0 errors) across two frozen collects, of which 448 walk-forward replays and origin re-runs · 66 verification sims (baseline runs inside the same collects; 0 equity replays needed)

MARKETMANIA RESEARCH TO DATE (as of cutoff): 93,429 directional forecasts resolved since Jul 11 (as of Nov 16, 2026 16:00 UTC cutoff) · 7 models tracked (current line-up; earlier versions folded into their successors' lineage) · 5 assets · 5 horizons · hourly · 78 published reports

*Counter pinned from wave 3 onward and read at the Nov 16, 2026 16:00 UTC cut-off: issue #14 printed 87,760 resolved and 74 published reports. The model line keeps the definition issue #4 introduced (7 tracked, current line-up; earlier versions folded into their successors' lineage), so the twelve issues' model counts are comparable. Config Watch #15 is the 78th published report.*

> **Issue #15.** The standing walk-forward board reaches 92 cards -- issue #14's 5 join it, and monthly and quarterly cards are judged by the weekly rule (Amendment 5). Two fresh windows again, the calendar week and the four calendar weeks ending at the same edge, both computed in the night collect as well as the week: the table keeps 37 of 92 past cards where the week alone keeps 62 and the month alone 41. The cross-window stability board is measured on this issue's own two windows (WK and M30) and comes back with **5** configurations. Formalization of the amendments is still slated for methodology v1.2.

---

## What we're testing next

- **The first fresh week of this issue's own cards.** Config Watch #16 replays the 5 cards published here that carry a short link (both WK councils, WK solo #1, both M30 councils; WK solo #2 and both M30 solo cards have no link and are not replayed, as issue #14's two unlinked solo cards were not) on its own fresh week, alongside the 92 already on the board. The number to check against: 80.0% of issue #14's 5 linked cards were net-positive on their first fresh week, which is this issue's week.
- **Whether the WK-and-M30 stability board reads the same twice.** 5 configurations are in the mature net top-40 of both windows of this issue's night run, against 4 on issue #14's board, 0 on issue #13's, 1 on issue #12's, 0 on issue #11's, 4 on issue #10's, 7 on issue #9's, 4 on issue #8's, 16 on issue #7's, 9 on issue #6's, 0 on issue #5's and 21 on issue #3's, all across the same pair. Config Watch #16's night run computes the same pair one week on, so the question is whether the count moves when the windows do.
- **What the calibrate share reads on a thirteenth window.** Calibration improves 7.2% of the 1,271 matched WK pairs and 32.3% of the 1,280 M30 pairs this issue, against 14.0% and 23.0% in issue #14. The test is the same two measurements on the next pair of windows -- the whole grid and the board-leader slice, reported separately and never pooled.

---

## Related research

- Consensus Watch #15 -- https://marketmania.ai/research/reports/consensus-watch-2026-11-09.pdf
- Weekly Calibration #15 -- https://marketmania.ai/research/reports/weekly-calibration-2026-11-09.pdf
- Weekly Model Watch #15 -- https://marketmania.ai/research/reports/model-watch-2026-11-09.pdf
- Config Watch #14 -- https://marketmania.ai/research/reports/config-watch-2026-11-04.pdf
- Config Watch #13 -- https://marketmania.ai/research/reports/config-watch-2026-10-28.pdf
- Monthly Config Watch #3 -- https://marketmania.ai/research/reports/config-watch-monthly-2026-10.pdf

*The three weekly reports publish together as one issue each week; Config Watch follows its own cycle. Market-regime figures, where this issue refers to them, come from that wave and are not re-tabulated here. Monthly Config Watch #3 is listed because its 3 cards are on the walk-forward table above.*

---

## Cite this report

```bibtex
@techreport{mm_configwatch_2026w47,
  title        = {Config Watch #15},
  author       = {{MarketMania Research}},
  institution  = {MarketMania},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = nov,
  day          = {18},
  type         = {Weekly Research Report},
  series       = {Config Watch},
  number       = {15},
  note         = {Methodology v1.1 + Config Watch amendments, hash e66c7e8c864a2233},
  url          = {https://marketmania.ai/research/reports/config-watch-2026-11-11.pdf}
}
```
